Josefine Bagger Sommerlund
Childhood toys worth more than you think.
Your childhood toys were more than just fun—they might be worth a small fortune today.
1. Pokémon Cards
- First edition “Charizard” (Shadowless, PSA 10) has sold for over $21,000
- Regular cards can still sell for hundreds of dollars
- Cards stored in original plastic sleeves and without wear are worth the most
2. Tamagotchi
- Original 1996 Tamagotchi in sealed packaging can be worth $280–560
- Used but working models typically sell for $40–110
- Japanese editions with unique designs are worth even more
3. Game Boy and Games
- Game Boy Color in original box: up to $210–420
- “Pokémon Red/Blue” in original packaging: up to $280–560
- Special limited editions can be even more valuable
4. Beanie Babies
- Ty Inc.’s small plush bears with name tags
- Some models are extremely rare (e.g., “Princess Diana Bear” – $28,000)
- Value: Can reach anywhere from $2,100 to $22,400
5. LEGO Sets
- LEGO Pirates “Black Seas Barracuda” (complete in box): up to $1,400
- Smaller sets from the 90s often sell for $70–420
- Unopened boxes are highly sought after
6. Action Figures
- TMNT figures in original packaging: up to $280 each
- Power Rangers Megazord set: up to $700
- Star Wars figures from 1995–99 can cost $70–420
7. Polly Pocket
- Complete 90s sets with box: up to $420–840
- Individual pieces or loose figures go for $30–85
- Sets produced before 1998 are the most valuable
8. Furbies
- Original 1998 Furby in unopened box: up to $350–560
- Special editions like “Tiger Stripes” or “Millennium” can be worth more
- Used models typically sell for $30–85
9. Barbie Dolls
- Holiday Barbie 1996 in original box: up to $140–350
- Rare editions from collectible series: $420+
- Accessories and original outfits increase the value
10. My Little Pony
- Rare ponies from the 90s can sell for $110–280
- Complete sets with box: up to $420
- Some models with glitter, scent, or color-changing features are extra valuable
11. Original Steiff Bears
- Signature: “Knopf im Ohr” (metal button in ear)
- Origin: Germany, from the early 1900s
- Value: Up to several thousands of dollars – rare models sell for over $7,000
12. American Girl Dolls (Pre-1990)
- Original dolls: Kirsten, Molly, Samantha
- Sell at high prices when in original packaging
- Rare models can be worth up to $1,400