Trump wins an important round against The New York Times in a bitter dispute over his financial history.
Donald Trump’s long-running feud with the American media has produced countless confrontations, but his latest courtroom battle could prove particularly uncomfortable for one of the country’s most prominent newspapers.
The president has spent years challenging reports about his personal wealth, business dealings and financial history. Now, a federal judge has given him an opportunity to pursue some of those grievances through a defamation lawsuit.
According to RadarOnline, US District Judge Steven Merryday ruled on November 19 that several claims in Trump’s lawsuit against The New York Times and other defendants could proceed, despite their attempts to have the case dismissed.
The decision represents a partial legal victory for Trump, although the court also rejected a substantial portion of his complaint.
Judge allows allegations involving Trump’s finances to face further scrutiny
The dispute concerns reporting about Trump’s financial history, including material published in Lucky Loser, a book written by New York Times journalists Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig.
Trump has challenged statements suggesting that he received more than $400 million from his father through arrangements allegedly involving tax evasion.
Other disputed allegations concern financial transactions purportedly designed to avoid inheritance and gift taxes, as well as claims involving investigations into alleged Mafia connections and violations of financial regulations.
Merryday’s 12-page ruling allowed four counts of Trump’s lawsuit to continue while dismissing two others.
The judge concluded that seven challenged statements were supported by sufficient allegations to make a plausible case that the defendants had acted with actual malice.
Crucially, however, the ruling did not establish that the journalists’ reporting was false or that defamation had occurred.
Judge questions whether journalists had sufficient evidence
A particularly significant part of the decision concerned the level of expertise required when journalists make allegations involving complicated financial crimes.
The New York Times and the other defendants argued that their reporting relied on extensive documentation, including approximately 100,000 pages of tax records, financial statements and other materials.
They also maintained that legal and tax specialists had been consulted during the investigation.
Merryday nevertheless questioned whether those consultations were sufficient to support particular allegations of criminal wrongdoing.
The judge distinguished between identifying potentially suspicious transactions and establishing that those transactions actually violated criminal law.
His ruling suggested that journalists who deliberately avoided obtaining necessary expert assessments could potentially meet the legal standard for reckless disregard of the truth.
“They know that they don’t know, but they are undeterred,” Merryday wrote.
The passage could become important as Trump’s lawyers attempt to demonstrate that the defendants published disputed allegations despite serious doubts about their accuracy.
Trump still faces a demanding legal challenge
Although the president secured permission to pursue several claims, the ruling was far from a complete victory.
Merryday dismissed two counts and found that 27 additional statements challenged by Trump could not support actionable defamation claims.
The judge also rejected Trump’s request to revise his complaint again.
Under established US Supreme Court precedent, public officials pursuing defamation lawsuits must demonstrate actual malice, meaning that the defendants either knew their statements were false or acted with reckless disregard for their accuracy.
That remains a demanding standard, particularly in cases involving investigative reporting about prominent political figures.
The New York Times and the other defendants now have 28 days to respond to the surviving allegations.