Camilla Jessen
Security analysts say the remarks could have wider implications for Europe and the war in Ukraine.
Tensions between the United States and its NATO allies are resurfacing following fresh comments from President Donald Trump.
Speaking at an investment forum in Miami, Trump questioned the value of NATO, saying: “We would have always stood by them, but now, given their actions, I think there’s no need for that, right?” according to the Kyiv Independent.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio echoed the sentiment days later, stating that Washington may need to “reevaluate” its relationship with NATO members.
Fears for alliance
The comments have raised alarm among security experts, who warn they could undermine confidence in NATO’s collective defence principle.
“Article 5 is now in very great danger,” François Heisbourg of the Foundation for Strategic Research told the outlet. “The situation is really serious.”
Article 5 is the cornerstone of NATO, committing members to defend one another in the event of an attack.
‘Gift’ to Moscow
Former US ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul criticised the remarks.
“President Trump’s statements are extremely disappointing,” he said. “They are yet another gift to (Russian President Vladimir) Putin.”
Analysts say such statements could embolden Russia as the war in Ukraine continues.
The dispute comes amid broader tensions between the US and European allies, particularly over the ongoing conflict involving Iran.
European governments have been reluctant to support US-led military actions in the region, with some leaders stating the conflict “is not Europe’s war.”
Rubio responded by drawing comparisons with Ukraine, noting the scale of US support in that conflict.
Jamie Shea, a former NATO official, said the alliance is increasingly being approached from a transactional perspective.
“NATO never meant that European allies would automatically support every American foreign policy adventure, but that’s what it’s becoming under Trump,” he said.
Uncertain future
Despite the tensions, some analysts suggest the situation could change quickly.
“Trump says a lot of things that don’t last long. He changes his mind quickly,” McFaul said, adding that US political dynamics could also shift.
Still, others warn that even temporary statements can have lasting effects.
Shea cautioned that such rhetoric may send “the wrong signals to Russia” and test NATO’s unity.
Sources: Kyiv Independent, statements from Michael McFaul, Digi24
