Homepage Politics “I certainly don’t agree”: Ted Cruz publicly rejects Vance’s Israel...

“I certainly don’t agree”: Ted Cruz publicly rejects Vance’s Israel takeaway from midterm loss

“I certainly don’t agree”: Ted Cruz publicly rejects Vance’s Israel takeaway from midterm loss
lev radin / Shutterstock

The Republican Party’s post-election autopsy spilled into public view on Sunday.

At the Jewish Leadership Conference in Manhattan, Texas Senator Ted Cruz drew a sharp line against Vice President JD Vance, telling a conservative audience he “certainly” disagreed with the vice president’s argument that the United States’ alliance with Israel helped sink Republicans in the 2026 midterms.

Asked by Tikvah Fund senior vice president Jonathan Silver about Vance’s efforts to cultivate an isolationist, anti-Israel wing of the party, Cruz replied:

“Anyone who looks at this election and sees a mandate to abandon Israel is seeing something I certainly don’t see, and I certainly don’t agree,” the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported from the Sunday afternoon event.

Asked about Vance’s motives, Cruz declined to speculate. “Look, you’ll have to ask JD his own reasons,” he told the audience.

What Vance actually wrote

Vance’s argument came in a lengthy November 4 post on X, hours after Republicans lost both chambers of Congress.

Citing a pollster he described as one of the smartest people he knows in politics, the vice president listed four motivations given by Trump 2024 voters who switched to Democrats in 2026: ending the Iran war, focusing on cost of living and inflation, putting “America First,” and changing the US relationship with Israel.

“Our voters showed up. And the above four reasons are why many of them voted for Democrats,” Vance wrote, while pointing to the Iran conflict as the overriding factor: “The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night”.

Click to display external content from x,
- You can always enable and disable third-party content.
You agree to display external third-party content. Personal data may be sent to the provider of the content and other third-party services.

Cruz’s wider warning

Cruz used the Manhattan stage to argue that antisemitic and anti-Israel rhetoric is gaining ground across the political spectrum.

On the left he named New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed.

On the right he named Tucker Carlson, Candace Owens, and former Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene, telling the audience that one-third of young people on the right are receptive to such messaging.

The country could “wake up in five years,” he warned, “and find ourselves in a country where both major political parties are unequivocally anti-Israel and unapologetically antisemitic.”

Cruz also pointed to his aligned group, Front Line Action, which targeted ads against Republican candidates James Fishback and Dan Bilzerian during the cycle in an effort to make antisemitism unacceptable inside the GOP.

A 2028 battle line

The clash is the most visible rupture yet between two Republicans most often floated for the 2028 presidential nomination, and it maps onto a live fight inside MAGA over the Iran war and the posture Washington should take toward Israel.

Vance has not publicly responded to Cruz’s remarks.

Ads by MGDK