A fight between Washington and Albany over who drives America’s trucks has been building since the summer of 2025.
The Trump administration has pushed blue-state governments to help revoke commercial driver’s licenses it says were improperly issued to immigrants.
New York refused, and lost tens of millions of dollars in federal highway funds when it did.
On Friday, a federal appeals court weighed in.
The Second US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Friday that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, part of the Department of Transportation, acted in a way that was “arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law” when it withheld nearly $74 million in federal highway money from New York.
The state had refused to cancel roughly 33,000 commercial driver’s licenses issued to immigrants.
The three-judge panel, in State of New York v. US Department of Transportation, said the state could not be penalized for failing to cancel licenses when the rule the agency relied on to require cancellation was not in place at the time the permits were issued.
The agency, the court found, had tried to impose a stricter standard on noncitizen drivers “out of regulatory silence,” an effort that “falls flat,” wrote Circuit Judge Allison Nathan.
The policy behind the penalty
The dispute traces back to an executive order President Trump signed on April 28, 2025. It directed the Transportation Department to resume enforcing English language proficiency rules for commercial drivers and to audit non-domiciled commercial driver’s licenses, the type most often issued to foreign nationals.
By summer 2025, enforcement had begun. By Nov. 13, 2026, about 26,000 drivers were pulled off the road for failing English tests, and roughly 30,000 licenses were canceled nationwide as improperly issued, PBS NewsHour reported.
Non-domiciled commercial licenses account for about 5% of all US commercial driver’s licenses, or roughly 200,000 drivers.
The pressure on New York followed an FMCSA audit that flagged tens of thousands of licenses the agency considered questionable. The state countered that regulators were inventing requirements after the fact.
At oral arguments in September, New York Assistant Solicitor General Anthony Raduazo called the government’s reasoning “a textbook post hoc rationalization,” language Nathan echoed in her opinion.
Before late 2025, federal regulations did not require matching commercial driver’s license expiration dates to a driver’s immigration documents. A new FMCSA rule, effective March 16, 2026, closed that gap by narrowing visa eligibility and tying license expiration to authorized stay dates.
The Second Circuit’s ruling only barred retroactive penalties for older licenses—it left the stricter 2026 rule intact going forward.
New York welcomes the ruling
Attorney General Letitia James brought the case in April, arguing the federal government was unfairly holding back money the state needed to repair roads and bridges.
Governor Kathy Hochul had earlier described the withholding as “devastating” and as “political payback.”
In a joint statement after the decision, Hochul and James called the ruling “a win for the millions of New Yorkers who rely on safe roads to travel,” according to WCAX.
The Department of Transportation defended its enforcement. “We’ve put a stop to the madness to keep the driving public safe,” the agency said in a statement, pointing to an August 2025 Florida crash in which a truck driver accused of making an illegal U-turn killed three people.
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy had said that driver should never have been licensed.
The withheld funds represent about 4% of New York’s federal highway and transportation money for fiscal 2027. Unless the administration asks the US Supreme Court to intervene, the money is expected to flow to the state.