Aksel Kryhlmand
If Milner finds the back of the net after turning 40, he’d become just the second outfield player to score at that age in Premier League history
James Milner has penned a one-year extension with Brighton & Hove Albion, giving him a real shot at overtaking Gareth Barry as the Premier League’s all-time appearance leader. It’s a significant milestone within reach for one of the league’s most enduring players.
Just 16 Matches Away from the Top Spot
With 638 Premier League appearances under his belt, Milner trails only Gareth Barry, who holds the record with 653. That leaves just 16 games between the 39-year-old and footballing immortality. Considering a season has 38 matches, Milner could feasibly claim the record by mid-season, if he stays fit.
A Veteran Among Legends
Milner already sits ahead of greats like Ryan Giggs (632) and Frank Lampard (609). His next target is Gareth Barry, who surpassed Giggs in 2017 to take the top spot. For perspective, only ten players in Premier League history have managed more than 500 appearances.
Injury Challenges Ahead
Last season was a frustrating one for Milner, as injuries limited him to just four appearances. At nearly 40, his durability is a concern. Yet Brighton boss Fabian Hurzeler sees Milner’s off-field influence as vital, calling him a mentor to younger players and a strong presence in the dressing room.
Unmatched Longevity in the Top Flight
Milner’s journey began in 2002 at just 16 years old with Leeds United. The upcoming season will be his 24th in the Premier League, a record. No player has featured in more seasons, with Giggs next on 22 and Barry on 21.
Closing in on the “40 Club”
Should Milner appear in a match after his 40th birthday on January 4, 2026, he’ll join a very exclusive group. Only four outfield players in Premier League history have played at that age, including Ryan Giggs and Teddy Sheringham.
Rare Air: Premier League’s Oldest Players
Most of the league’s oldest players have been goalkeepers, led by John Burridge, who played at 43. The oldest outfield star? Sheringham at 40 years and 272 days. Milner could become the fifth to cross that milestone, finishing the season at 40 years and 139 days.
Goal at 40? Only One Has Done It
If Milner finds the back of the net after turning 40, he’d become just the second outfield player to score at that age in Premier League history. The only one to do so? Sheringham again, at 40 years and 268 days.
A Timeless Career Still Going Strong
Whether he sets the appearance record, plays past 40, or even scores another goal, Milner’s career is already historic. From a teenage debut with Leeds to title-winning spells with Manchester City and Liverpool, his journey continues to defy expectations.