Homepage US US Supreme Court turns away Trump bid to cut DEI-related...

US Supreme Court turns away Trump bid to cut DEI-related grants in up to $1 billion fight

Donald Trump
Joey Sussman / Shutterstock.com

Citing “napkin math,” an attorney for the researchers estimated that the lower-court rulings left intact by the justices have restored up to $1 billion in total grant value.

A politically charged showdown over who gets to pull the plug on federally funded research reached the US Supreme Court in August.

The dispute pulled in six University of California researchers, three federal science and humanities agencies, and the question of whether Washington can cut a grant because of what the research is about.

On Monday, the justices gave their answer without hearing a word of argument.

The Supreme Court turned away the Trump administration’s appeal seeking to cancel National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities grants awarded to University of California researchers. No justice noted a dissent, and the court, as it usually does on such petitions, gave no explanation.

The exact dollar amount at stake is unsettled. While some reports have pegged the disputed grants at roughly $150 million, the Trump administration estimated in court filings that approximately $59 million remained on the NSF and NEH awards at issue.

Meanwhile, an attorney for the UC researchers estimated via “napkin math” that the broader litigation could restore up to $1 billion in total grant funding across federal agencies.

The order leaves intact a May 26, 2026 decision by a three-judge panel of the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals, which found the cancellations were likely unconstitutional because they were “aimed at the suppression of viewpoints with which the government disagrees.”

Viewpoint discrimination at the core

The 9th Circuit’s analysis targeted how the grants had been cut. The panel concluded that the agencies had selected grants for termination based solely on recipients’ perceived support for DEI or environmental justice initiatives, rather than on neutral programmatic limits.

Researchers told the justices, according to Insight into Academia, that no court had ever held that a president and federal agencies may terminate grants “awarded through a merit-driven competitive process based on the perceived viewpoint” of the research.

The Justice Department countered in its filings that the First Amendment “does not prohibit the government from declining to award competitive grants that fund research projects that promote DEI.”

A venue that lets money flow faster

Just as important as the free-speech holding is where the fight will be waged. The 9th Circuit set up a two-track system following a recent Supreme Court precedent on NIH grants: constitutional challenges stay in federal district court, while contract-based claims for monetary damages must go to the Court of Federal Claims.

By leaving that framework untouched, the Supreme Court kept the main case in district court, where judges can order agencies to restart payments rather than wait on a slower damages track. The underlying class action was filed in June 2025 in the Northern District of California.

The agencies had terminated the UC grants after sending form letters that flagged projects tied to “environmental justice,” “diversity, equity, and inclusion,” or “gender ideology.”

Ads by MGDK